
Haunted Houses Are Scary and Tough to Beat in Court
Haunted Houses Are Scary and Tough to Beat in Court
Every October, millions of Americans willingly step into haunted houses, corn mazes and darkened trails, hoping for a good scare. But when a startled patron runs into a wall, trips over uneven ground, or falls while fleeing a costumed actor, the fright can give way to litigation.
These cases raise a surprisingly tricky question: How much risk does someone accept when they pay to be scared?
Courts have often recognized that startling patrons is central to a haunted attraction’s appeal. But where the scare happens, what patrons reasonably expect, and how the attraction operates can complicate the analysis.
For litigators, the details matter: where a patron was standing, when the scare occurred, and what the attraction led that person to expect.
Who Would Pay for a Non-Scary Haunted House?
Take the case of Griffin v. The Haunted Hotel Inc., 242 Cal.App.4th 490 (2015), arising from a haunted trail attraction that featured the so-called “Carrie effect.” The “Carrie effect,” named after the 1976 horror movie Carrie, is executed when the attraction operator lulls patrons into believing their haunted experience is over and then springs one final scare on unsuspecting thrill seekers. In Griffin, the plaintiff was having a fine time — in fact, he believed the thrilling portion of the evening had concluded — when an actor wielding a gas-powered chainsaw approached him. The actor gave chase when the plaintiff attempted to flee the scene. The plaintiff fell, sustaining injuries.
The plaintiff testified at his deposition:
He was pointing it [the chainsaw] right at me, and it was live and active; you could literally smell the gas … hear the sound and everything. Yes, I felt like he was handling that very dangerously. It was a real chainsaw. This gentleman did not keep a safe distance, and the more I backed away, the more he followed me. I asked him to stop; he wouldn’t. I started running. He was literally running after me.
The attraction’s representative, during his deposition, articulated a different view:
You scare the hell out of them as much as you possibly can, and that’s what they’re paying us for, that’s why they come. He [the plaintiff] ran. He chose to run. You can’t chase a human that doesn’t run. If he had just stood there and said “stop,” then it’s not fun. You move on. You scare somebody else.
That’s pretty much how the Griffin court assessed the situation. Griffin held that the doctrine of primary assumption of the risk called for summary judgment in favor of Haunted Hotel. This is a case, the court said, where a recreational activity carries an inherent risk of injury to voluntary participants that cannot be eliminated without altering the fundamental nature of the activity. Liability can be established if the plaintiff’s injuries were the result of reckless behavior or an intent to cause harm, however.
The court observed that the entire point of the Haunted Trail is to scare people, which carries the inherent risk that someone will get scared and react by running away. As the trial court put it, “[W]ho would want to go to a haunted house that is not scary?”
When Does the Scare Experience Begin?
In Durmon v. Billings, No. 38,514-CA (La. Ct. App., May 12, 2004), a chainsaw-wielding character emerged from a corn maze wearing an orange jumpsuit and white hockey goalie mask. The plaintiff turned and ran, fell, and broke her leg. The trial court entered summary judgment for the operator, and the appellate court affirmed. The court concluded that the operator did not owe a duty to protect the plaintiff from her reaction to a frightening experience she expected and had paid an additional admission fee to encounter.
But what if a patron has not yet entered the attraction?
That question complicated Davis v. Dungeons of Delhi, No. C-180242 (Ohio Ct. App., Apr. 19, 2019). According to the complaint, the plaintiff was crossing adjoining property toward the haunted house when a worker dressed as a ghoul emerged, frightened her, and chased her, causing her to fall and sustain injuries.
The trial court granted summary judgment to the operator, but the appellate court reversed. Questions remained about whether the area outside the house was part of the attraction and whether patrons should have expected the scares to begin there.
Unlike the patron in Griffin, who believed the frightening experience had ended, the plaintiff in Davis maintained that hers had not yet begun. That distinction gave her claims another chance in court.
Jason Strikes Yet Again
Finally, in Galan v. Covenant House New Orleans, 695 So.2d 1007 (La.App.1997), the notorious serial tortfeasor Jason was up to his old tricks again. As in Griffin, the haunted house attraction operator was working the “Carrie effect” subterfuge, leading patrons down a flight of stairs to a harmless-looking doorway marked “exit,” which, as we all know, was not an exit but was, in fact, a perilous locale where Jason lay in wait. With his chainsaw and an orange jumpsuit and hockey goalie mask. According to the complaint, the noise from the chainsaw frightened the plaintiff, causing her to fall and strike her head, sustaining injuries.
The plaintiff’s lawyers took dead aim at the “Carrie effect.” They argued that the haunted house operator created an unreasonably dangerous risk of harm by placing their last exhibit outside of the exit to the haunted house, at a point where patrons would no longer expect to be frightened.
The appellate court disagreed. The purpose of a haunted house is to frighten patrons — a fact that the plaintiff admitted in her deposition, the court noted.
“[T]he fact that the plaintiff did not expect this last exhibit does not mandate that the exhibit is unreasonable,” it ruled. “Patrons in a Halloween haunted house are expected to be surprised, startled and scared by the exhibits but the operator does not have a duty to guard against patrons reacting in bizarre, frightened and unpredictable ways.”
A Little Something Extra in Your Treat Bag: In Mays v. Gretna Athletic Boosters, 668 So. 2d 1207 (La. Ct. App. 5th Cir. Jan. 17, 1996), a 10-year-old child ran into a cinder-block wall in a makeshift haunted house attraction while trying to escape someone who had jumped out of the darkness and scared her. The trial court held that the operator had no duty to protect patrons from reacting in “bizarre, frightened and unpredictable ways.”
Be Careful Out There
These cases show that even a Halloween scare can raise serious questions about expectations, responsibility, and the risks people agree to take. For litigators, the details matter: where a patron was standing, when the scare occurred and what the attraction led that person to expect.
For everyone heading out this Halloween, a little attention to your surroundings can help keep a good fright from becoming a real injury.
Happy Halloween from Esquire, and stay safe out there.

